What's
the dream matchup in
UFC MMA?, you'd likely get only one answer:
Anderson Silva vs. Georges St. Pierre. And for years, this was the dream
fight to end all dream
fights. It was
MMA's equivalent to Manny Pacquiao vs. Floyd Mayweather, only (us
MMA fans bragged then) this
fight actually stood a good chance of happening. People were talking about this MMA
fight as far back as 2006, when both
St. Pierre and
Silva first strapped on
UFC belts. The talk ramped up in 2008, when
GSP won his belt back from
Matt Serra and
Anderson Silva “ran out” of challengers at
middleweight for the first of about 900 times. For nearly half a decade, the top two slots in the special
MMA “Circular, Subjective Argument Generator”—otherwise known as the top five pound-for-pound list—were traded between
Silva and
St. Pierre. Both guys fortunes rose and fell, each guy racing momentarily ahead of the other.
GSP dominates
Thiago Alves while
Silva dances around
Thales Leites?
GSP must be the man!
Anderson Silva transcends the laws of physics to murder
Forrest Griffin while
GSP wrestles
Dan Hardy’s arm for 25 minutes? Guess Andy is back on top! Folks would argue
GSP’s wrestling would exploit the only weakness in
Anderson Silva’s game. People said
Anderson Silva’s striking would expose
GSP’s fragile chin. There were theories and speculation galore. And any day now, we would see them
fight. 2009 was the year, fans said. Then 2010. Then 2011. Now it's 2012, and fans are turning blue in the face, mostly from holding their breath in anticipation for this
fight.
Is St. Pierre vs. Silva Officially Dead?
With
St. Pierre on the shelf and
Anderson nearing the end of his
MMA fighting reign on dominance, the question begs to be asked: Is
Silva vs. St. Pierre fight officially dead? And more than that, if it isn't dead from a timing/booking standpoint, is it dead from a fan interest standpoint? Would anyone out there still consider this the "Mecca" of
MMA fights?
And if it isn't "dead," what are the chances we see this
fight before one (or both) men fall off their athletic peaks, assuming they haven't already? I think the earlier Pac/Floyd comparison is quite apt, because this fight too would pit a
fighter who is nice, polite, idolized by his home fans and catching tons of flack over his last fight, against perhaps the most technically perfect
fighter in the game whose personality no one can figure out. Yes, this
fight was the dream
fight to end all
MMA dream
fights, and at various times, it looked close to being booked. But just like my "foolproof" plan in high school to wed
Jessica Biel before I was 20...well, sometimes things just don't work out like you plan.
I remember
George St. Pierre first getting asked about a possible
Anderson Silva fight at
UFC 100 after he beat
Thiago Alves. While accepting the
fight in principal, he stated that moving up in weight would be a significant shift for him, that he'd have to talk it over with his coaches and entourage and that it really depended on what the
UFC had next for him.
GSP must have that speech committed to memory, because it's the same canned speech he gives every time
Joe Rogan asks about facing
Anderson during the
post-fight interview. Now I love me some
GSP, and lots of what he's saying makes total sense. But even I got to admit this is starting to sound like foot-dragging of some pretty epic proportions.
Sometimes GSP seems less than eager to face Silva (and who could blame him?)
Maybe
St. Pierre himself doesn’t want the
Anderson Silva fight, and as a guy making seven figures a
fight, absolutely tearing up the
PPV charts and totally dominating the competition in his weight class, who could really blame him for not wanting to change divisions? If he does want the fight, then perhaps someone in his entourage doesn’t think it’s a good idea or is advising him not to commit to the
fight in interviews to increase leverage for negotiations. Or maybe it’s the
UFC itself urging
GSP to fence sit, wary of the inevitability that for this
fight to happen, one golden goose has to eat another. And
Anderson? The long-time
middleweight champ once said his ideal opponent would be a clone of himself, which is ideal considering one of the biggest obstacles to making this fight is
Silva himself. Remember in early ’09, when all the buzz around the
St. Pierre vs. BJ Penn fight had people buzzing about the
other great P4P clash? Then,
Anderson stunk up the Bell Centre for 25 minutes against Thales Leites, and fans vowed never to buy an
Anderson Silva PPV again.
Then the next year, serious talk about making this
fight happen began to swirl again.
GSP was even brought in to guest commentate the
Silva vs. Maia main event at
UFC 112 and would have ostensibly confronted him in the ring afterwards. Except that
Silva vs. Maia happened,
Dana White was furious and once again, fans vowed never to buy another
Anderson Silva PPV.
Silva got
Sonnen, GSP got
The Ultimate Fighter and the rest is history. So here’s my question to you: Is this
fight still “on the table?" Is there a realistic chance of making this
fight happen, and if so, when? And more than that: Does this fight still
mean anything to fans? Is it still the big deal it was only two short years ago? Or have other potential “superfights” involving the likes of
Jon Jones, Junior Dos Santos, Jose Aldo and Dominick Cruz taken the spot of
GSP/Silva as the fight
MMA fans want to see? go to
www.ufc.com voice your opinion Come Dana Lets get
Anderson Silva vs.
George St. Pierre on the fight card of the century! Only in the
UFC....